Constant Gardener, The

starstarstar

A movie review by James Berardinelli



Constant Gardener, The

THRILLER:

United States/United Kingdom, 2005

U.S. Release Date:

2005-08-31

Running Length:

2:09

MPAA Classification:

R (Violence, Profanity, Sexual Situations, Nudity)

Theatrical Aspect Ratio:

1.85:1

Cast:

Ralph Fiennes, Rachel Weisz, Danny Huston, Bill Nighy, Pete Postlethwaite, Gerard McSorley, Hubert Koundé

Director:

Fernando Meirelles

Screenplay:

Jeffrey Caine, based on the novel by John Le Carré

Cinematography:

César Charlone

Music:

Alberto Iglesias

U.S. Distributor:

Universal Pictures

Subtitles:

none


For his follow-up to City of God, Brazilian director Fernando Meirelles has elected to adapt John Le Carré's The Constant Gardener into movie form. A slow-burn thriller simmering with international intrigue, the book would at first seem too long and complex to be crammed into a two-hour motion picture. But Jeffrey Caine's screenplay does a solid job of distilling the essence of the novel into something manageable, and Meirelles' kinetic, in-your-face style lends energy and immediacy to the proceedings.

This is not a thriller designed for the crowd that prefers shoot-outs, chases, and other action-packed incidents. The Constant Gardener is talky and intelligent, and never takes the cheap way out. It's also something of a downer, both it terms of how the main characters are handled and in its cynical attitude toward the pharmaceutical industry. There's no mistaking The Constant Gardener for anything other than a "message movie." Yes, there's also a love story here, but the most powerful aspect of the movie is what it has to say about the way medicines are tested in third world nations without the consideration of negative side effects, and how bad things that happen during these trials are covered up. The Constant Gardener is fiction, but the incidents it portrays are based on real-world events from Africa and Asia.

The first character we meet is Justin Quayle (Ralph Fiennes), a soft-spoken British diplomat in Kenya. Within a few minutes, we learn that his young wife, Tessa (Rachel Weisz), has been killed while traveling in a jeep along a lonely stretch of highway. The official cause of death is a bandit raid, but Tessa was a known activist, and Justin suspects a cover-up. There are other loose ends. Was Tessa having an affair with Arnold Bluhm (Hubert Koundé), the black doctor who accompanied her on many of her trips? And why was she obsessed with a new drug being used to cure TB? His superiors (Danny Huston, Bill Nighy) are tight-lipped and urge him to drop the matter, as well as to return a letter that Tessa allegedly stole - if he should happen to find it, that is. At the root of his investigation lies Justin's need to determine whether Tessa loved and was faithful to him. The more he probes into her life and the nature of her activism, the more galvanized he is to act. Through Justin's mission, we learn as much about Tessa after her death as we do during the 30 minutes of flashbacks that occur early in the film.

Meirelles makes the movie as much about Justin and Tessa's relationship as about the political situation, although his docu-drama style (with lots of hand-held camera shots) works against strong character identification. Justin never comes vividly to life, and his romance with Tessa engages us on an intellectual, but not emotional, level. Perhaps this is because Justin is a reticent man, and the story is told from his point-of-view. Regardless, we understand how each revelation changes Justin's comprehension of his relationship with his late wife, but feeling for him is another matter.

Meirelles has chosen his cast for acting ability rather than name recognition. Ralph Fiennes and Rachel Weisz are perfect for the roles. He brings a cool reserve to his part. Justin is a gentle individual, a tender of flowers who would rather talk than act. Fiennes captures the essence of such a man, and how he reacts when pushed. Weisz, despite being in less than half the movie, is a firecracker, and Tessa's shadow looms large even when she's not around. She brings passion and energy to the part; The Constant Gardener crackles when she's on-screen. In secondary roles, Pete Postlethwaite (as a field doctor in the Sudan) and Bill Nighy are exceptional. Gerard McSorley is memorable as a knighted thug. The only one to strike a slightly "off" note is Danny Huston, who is miscast as Justin's slimy boss.

Like Hotel Rwanda, another film about atrocities in modern-day Africa, The Constant Gardener's biggest challenge may be finding an audience. Despite being based on a Le Carré book, the final product is more reminiscent of City of God than it is something from the pen of the world's foremost spy novelist. Yet, despite the lack of surprises and cheap theatrics, there is plenty of tension and drama, and the acting by Fiennes and Weisz is top notch. The Constant Gardener is a movie with something to say, and it speaks its message loudly and with eloquence. The only question is: how many people will hear it?





Movie Review Query Engine Top Critic Featured Critic - Movie Review Intelligence

Quick Archives...



Member of the The Online Film Critics Society