An A/B ComparisonJanuary 16, 2008
I normally don't write ReelThoughts columns on Wednesday, but I performed an "unintentional experiment" last night and I wanted to report on the results because they could be seen as contradicting a recommendation I made on Monday. Read on if you're interested...
Last night, I sat down in my cozy home theater to watch two movies: one on HD-DVD and one on standard DVD. I watched the high def film first. As expected, the picture was crystal clear and the sound was well balanced. Whatever Toshiba's faults, the HD-DVD format delivers what it claims to and the HD-A30 is a nice piece of hardware. Then, since the HD-DVD player was already warmed up, I used it as my upconverting DVD player and stuck in the standard DVD.
Admittedly, the transfer was crappy but the HD-A30 did a terrible job with the disc. There were motion artifacts, stutter-stopping, and all sorts of other problems. After eight minutes, I turned it off. Then, for the hell of it, I put it in the PS3 to see if the Sony had any better success. To my amazement, the DVD played smoothly and without problems, and looked about as good as I could expect given the poor quality of the transfer. This got me wondering about how good the HD-DVD player's DVD upconversion process is. So I decided to perform a little experiment. (For those who are wondering, the TV and receiver are the same and all connections are HDMI.)
For my next "test," I pulled 300 off the shelf. I have already done an A/B comparison of this movie on Blu-Ray and HD-DVD and found there to be no difference. I popped the HD-DVD version into the HD-A30 player and, as expected, it looked great. No problems there. Then I went to work using the standard DVD version (which I purchased before going high def). Played in the PS3, it looked almost high-def. Not quite, but close. In the HD-A30, it seemed less impressive. Not bad to be sure, but to an untrained eye, not as good as in the PS3. So I dragged out an upconverting Panasonic standard DVD player (with an HDMI interface) and took a look at 300 in that. It looked similar to the HD-DVD presentation.
Admittedly, there's nothing scientific about this "study" but, as A/B comparisons go, it raised a few red flags. It makes me wonder about the quality of the HD-DVD's upconversion process, especially in comparison to that of the PS3. I have no axes to grind here. In fact, had I not noticed issues with the HD-A30's inability to effectively play a standard disc, I never would have put it in the PS3. Could it just be my player? That's a possibility, although there are no problems with the high def aspects of it. But if you're considering buying an HD-DVD player to use as an upconverting DVD player, this is issue that bears additional investigation. It re-enforces my belief that if you're considering buying a high def player, Blu-Ray is the way to go. (And, based on nearly everyone I have discussed this with, the PS3 is the best low-end Blu-Ray player available.) Even at an ultra-cheap price, I'm not sure I'd purchase a HD-DVD player if the DVD upconversion was a primary feature.
This surprised and disappointed me. I'd love to hear from others who have had similar or contrary experiences. If I get enough e-mails, I'll post a summary in a future column. But I won't be using the HD-A30 for watching any more standard DVDs. Doesn't make sense when they look better on the PS3.
The Self-Serving Column
Initially, this ReelThought was going to be about the insane, must-be-first mindset that is driving film critics' groups to announce their end-of-the-year awards before they have seen the entire roster of 2011 films. It's the same mentality that is ...
Once, the concept of a "midnight screening" was reserved for the specialist of special blockbuster movies - films for which fans would stand in line for days or even weeks just so they could be among the first to see it on the big screen. (Remember ...
A Festival Comes to Town
In the film festival pantheon, there are three levels of prestige. Tier One is inhabited by The Giants. Cannes and Toronto are the only undisputed members of this select group. Some would argue that Venice belongs there, or Telluride, or Berlin. ...